A daily dose of philosophical food for your noodle!
NoodleFood : RSS Feed | via E-mail | Recent Comments | Archives
NoodleCast : M4A via iTunes (MP3) | via Feed Reader | via E-mail
Diana Hsieh : Rationally Selfish | PhiloFiles | Explore Atlas Shrugged
OList Mailing Lists | FIRM | FRO | Secular Government

 Monday, July 07, 2008

OCON Wrap Up

By Diana Hsieh @ 3:09 PM

Now that OCON is over and done, NoodleFood will resume its regular blogging on matters of more general interest. I do hope that folks enjoyed the reports, even though usually pretty brief. I'd love to hear whether people might be more (or less!?!) interested in attending an OCON as a result.

(Written and posted from my iPhone in the airport.)

Labels: ,

Share |
   E-mail Diana Hsieh     PermaLink ()    Comments (New Page)

  Subscribe to NoodleFood Blog Posts via Feed Reader   via E-mail
Subscribe to NoodleCast Podcasts M4A via iTunes (MP3)   via Feed Reader   via E-mail

 Sunday, July 06, 2008

Highlights from OCON: Day 8

By Diana Hsieh @ 11:26 PM

Here are highlights from the Ayn Rand Institute's summer conference (a.k.a. OCON), Day Eight:

Yaron Brook on "Cultural Movements: Creating Change," Lecture 3 of 3:
  • Yaron Brook gave a compelling speech on the desperate need for grassroots activism to help turn around the culture in the next 20 years, including some ideas for how to do so. ARI and Objectivist intellectuals cannot do all the necessary work on their own. I won't repeat what he said here, as I believe that these three lectures on activism will be made available for free on the "activism" section of the ARI web site. I cannot recommend listening to them highly enough.

  • Happily, Yaron cited Lin Zinser's FIRM as a positive example of grassroots activism. Of course, for anyone interested in activism to promote Objectivist ideas in the culture, I strongly recommend joining my OActivists mailing list. I've got big plans for it to be implemented in the next month or so.

  • Unfortunately, my enjoyment of this captivating lecture was marred by a very irritating request about halfway through from the person sitting next to me. She was bothered by the perfectly ordinary noise of my typing notes on my computer, and somehow I was obliged to move to another seat. That pretty much killed my concentration for the rest of the lecture. I was literally unable to comprehend what Yaron was saying for a few minutes. I was so irritated because I wasn't doing anything abnormal or inappropriate, I was in my seat with my computer before she arrived, and she ought to have moved if she's sensitive. I have no idea who the person was, but I'm still irritated, as I won't be able to remember the event without remembering that most unwelcome interruption. BLECH!
Eric Daniels on Freedom of Speech in American History, Lecture 3 of 3:
  • Today, Eric Daniels covered the state of the law in various kind of free speech, particularly obscenity law, fighting words and hate speech, and symbolic speech.

  • He also advocated three strategies in any attempt to defend freedom of speech. I'll list them here, although they only really make sense in the context of the whole course.

    1. Articulate and advocate a proper view of free speech, based on the proper grounds of individual rights and the exercise of reason.
    2. Defend even the worst speech on principle.
    3. Argue that free speech is not just about politics but about all aspects of man’s life.
Paul and I will be returning home tomorrow. I'm looking forward to that, although apparently it's hot hot hot in Denver.

Labels: ,

Share |
   E-mail Diana Hsieh     PermaLink ()    Comments (New Page)

  Subscribe to NoodleFood Blog Posts via Feed Reader   via E-mail
Subscribe to NoodleCast Podcasts M4A via iTunes (MP3)   via Feed Reader   via E-mail

 Saturday, July 05, 2008

Highlights from OCON: Day 7

By Diana Hsieh @ 11:58 PM

Here are highlights from the Ayn Rand Institute's summer conference (a.k.a. OCON), Day Seven:

Eric Daniels on Freedom of Speech in American History, Lecture 2 of 3:
  • Once again, Eric's class was the only lecture I attended today. It was an excellent survey of the change in thinking about free speech during the progressive era, but I'm too tired to say more. I'll try to blog more on his whole course tomorrow.
Now to bed!

Labels: ,

Share |
   E-mail Diana Hsieh     PermaLink ()    Comments (New Page)

  Subscribe to NoodleFood Blog Posts via Feed Reader   via E-mail
Subscribe to NoodleCast Podcasts M4A via iTunes (MP3)   via Feed Reader   via E-mail

OCON Notes From Kendall J

By Paul Hsieh @ 1:39 PM

Kendall J has also been blogging about his OCON experience. You can read his notes here:
"Notes from the UnderCON" (July 2, 2008)
"Notes from the UnderCON II" (July 4, 2008)
Yet another OBlogger that we've been happy to meet in person!

Labels:

Share |
   E-mail Paul Hsieh     PermaLink ()    Comments (New Page)

  Subscribe to NoodleFood Blog Posts via Feed Reader   via E-mail
Subscribe to NoodleCast Podcasts M4A via iTunes (MP3)   via Feed Reader   via E-mail

 Friday, July 04, 2008

Highlights from OCON: Day 6

By Diana Hsieh @ 11:50 PM

Here are highlights from the Ayn Rand Institute's summer conference (a.k.a. OCON), Day Six:

Eric Daniels on Freedom of Speech in American History, Lecture 1 of 3:
  • Two words perfectly summarize the opening lecture of this course: Freakin' Awesome. Eric Daniels -- my very, very favorite of all the fabulous Objectivist lecturers -- offered an hour and fifteen minutes of uber-high-bandwidth information on free speech. It was clear, comprehensible, and compelling. (I had no trouble taking copious good notes.) And, Eric looked at his notes once or twice the whole time -- maybe. So as I said: Freakin' Awesome.

  • This lecture covered three foundational questions: (1) Do we have free speech today? (2) What is free speech? and (3) Why does free speech matter? (His answer for the third was particularly interesting in his emphasis on the epistemological roots of the right of free speech.) Eric then discussed -- in some detail -- the early history of free speech in America, particularly the state of English law on free speech (fascinating!), the First Amendment and the Sedition Act (not your father's view!), and the restrictions on abolitionist speech in the mid-1830s (familiar ground for me, but now better integrated and understood).
Since I'm only taking one optional course this week, that single class was my whole conference today. So I spent some time working on my dissertation, talking with friends, and goofing off. Plus I got in a painfully good workout.

Finally, Paul and I had a particularly delightful dinner with friends -- the kind of evening that I hope to vividly and fondly recall 50 years from now. That was beyond fantastic.

Oh and I forgot to mention this tidbit earlier: As of a few days ago, OCON 2008 had 455 attendees -- and that was still growing. It's a darn big conference.

Labels: ,

Share |
   E-mail Diana Hsieh     PermaLink ()    Comments (New Page)

  Subscribe to NoodleFood Blog Posts via Feed Reader   via E-mail
Subscribe to NoodleCast Podcasts M4A via iTunes (MP3)   via Feed Reader   via E-mail

 Thursday, July 03, 2008

Highlights from OCON: Day 5

By Diana Hsieh @ 11:53 PM

Here are highlights from the Ayn Rand Institute's summer conference (a.k.a. OCON), Day Five:

Tore Boeckmann on "The Novels of Ayn Rand and the Metaphysics of Value"
  • Tore Boeckmann offered a fascinating look at the concrete values in Ayn Rand's fiction in relation to the theme of the work, particularly the significance of the incidental elements or aspects of those values, such as Howard Roark's gaunt, angular figure. This lecture offered a level of literary analysis well beyond my meager understanding, so I plan to be on the lookout for this new complexity when I next reread Ayn Rand's novels, particularly her more developed works The Fountainhead and Atlas Shrugged.
Onkar Ghate on "Cultural Movements: Creating Change"
  • Onkar Ghate gave a fantastically chilling lecture on the rise of religion in American politics, beginning with the Goldwater campaign. His case for the deliberate infiltration of politics by evangelical Christianity was clear, systematic, and undeniable. Further details may be found in a source used by Dr. Ghate himself, one that I've repeatedly recommended, namely With God on Our Side: The Rise of the Religious Right in America by sociologist William Martin.

  • Toward the end of his lecture, Dr. Ghate observed the following, as recorded in my abbreviated notes: Increasing numbers of Christians are recognizing the contemporary evangelical Christianity is too easy, too soft: it doesn't recognize man's inherently sinful nature. Moreover, the younger evangelicals are not interested in the free markets espoused by the older generation but rather in environmentalism and poverty. So religion needs environmentalism -- and vice versa. Environmentalism offers religion its necessary doomsday scenario according to which your mere existence is a sin. Religion offers environmentalism a widely-held philosophic foundation, as Yaron Brook argued a few days ago. Until now, religionists have been primarily concerned with the spiritual realm, i.e. with sex. Yet many recognize that the message of Christianity is far more broad, far more reaching than that. Correspondingly, environmentalism has been primarily concerned with the material realm, i.e. with industry. The merger of them is a natural outgrowth of their current trajectories -- and very dangerous.
Academic Panel:
  • As usual, the Academic Panel had tons of news to report, but since I arrived late and without my computer, I didn't take notes. If you want to know what's happening with Ayn Rand in academia, I'd recommend donating to the newly-expanded Anthem Foundation, so that you can enjoy the regular progress reports.
Now, bedtime!

Labels: ,

Share |
   E-mail Diana Hsieh     PermaLink ()    Comments (New Page)

  Subscribe to NoodleFood Blog Posts via Feed Reader   via E-mail
Subscribe to NoodleCast Podcasts M4A via iTunes (MP3)   via Feed Reader   via E-mail

OCON: Q&A Session with Leonard Peikoff

By Paul Hsieh @ 11:01 PM

As many readers know, Dr. Leonard Peikoff gave a special Q&A session for attendees of OCON 2008 on July 2, 2008. I've chosen to summarize a few selected questions, not necessarily in the order that they were asked. These are paraphrases from my notes and not verbatim quotes, so any errors or inadvertent inaccuracies are purely my own, not his. He took a mixture of nearly 40 written and spoken questions. The session lasted 90 minutes, with a 5 minute intermission halfway through.

He and the ARI established a few ground rules ahead of time. In particular, he stated that he wouldn't comment on the 2008 Presidential election. He also gave an update on the status of his forthcoming book on the DIM hypothesis as well as his podcasting activities. Overall, he was in an cheerful benevolent mood, and there were many touches of humor that I can't easily capture in this blog post. His mind was razor sharp, and it was good to see him at his best.

I don't know if an audio recording of this session will be subsequently released as a CD from the Ayn Rand Bookstore or on his podcast. If I learn more, I'll post an update.

My own comments will be in square brackets ("[]").

=====

Book update: The book is going both "badly" and well. It is going "badly" in the sense that he has completed a preliminary draft of the entire book, but now has to do a lot of heavy editing of the earlier chapters.

It is going well in the sense that he is now fully convinced of the correctness of his DIM hypothesis, based on the research he has done. And he is enjoying the writing process and is happy with the quality of the work. The book should be completed by Christmas 2010 at the very latest.

Podcast update: He enjoys doing the podcast tremendously. He is pleased with the quality of the questions and believes that the questions submitted are of better quality than in the past. He is also happy with the improved audio quality. He hopes that his answers are spurring his listeners to pursue some of these ideas in greater depth by looking for more information in the rest of the Objectivist literature. Also, he finds the podcasting to be a nice break from his book writing.

The podcasts will now be available on iTunes, which any users can subscribe to for free!

[I think this is terrific news, since this will make it easier to transfer files back and forth from my iPod, rather than having to do the downloads through the Peikoff.com website.]

Q) What philosophical or cultural trend is the most dangerous?

A) Religion.

Q) Will the rise of environmentalism and the subsequent loss of freedoms bring us to a society like that portrayed in Anthem?

A) Yes and no. Environmentalism does pose a danger to our freedoms. But the society depicted in Anthem is a fictional one which projects the idea of collectivism in its purest form. In our case, he believes that a different bad outcome would be more likely -- one in which we are ruled by a Pope rather than a "Council of Scholars".

Q) Who are the "low hanging fruit" most likely to be receptive to Objectivist ideas, i.e., the best targets to reach?

A) In his experience, young people between ages 17-29. Before age 17, they are generally too young and not ready to digest these ideas. After age 30, they are more likely to stop thinking as they will have finished deciding their basic values. With respect to specific professions, he's noticed that engineers, computer people, and doctors seem to be disproportionately represented in Objectivist circles.

Q) What are your favorite artworks in the following specific categories -- novel, play, painting, sculpture, and song?

A) His favorites are:
Novel - Atlas Shrugged
Play - Cyrano de Bergerac
Painting - The Creation of Adam (Michelangelo)
Sculpture - The Dying Slave (Michelangelo)
Song - He doesn't know which is his favorite, but it's not "God Save the King" (the first song title that popped into his head when he heard the question).
Q) As a gay Objectivist, there seem to be a disproportionate number of other gays in the Objectivist community relative to the population at large. Is there an explanation for this?

A) "Is that a problem?" [Lots of laughter, and the questioner said, no that wasn't a problem at all for him.] Basically, it's hard to know if there actually is over-representation or under-representation given the small numbers. Perhaps if there were 20 million Objectivists we could ask the question and attempt an answer. But the numbers are currently too small to attempt to answer this question or even to know if the premise is true.

Q) Is there a proper role for government in environmental issues where there are collective action questions -- for instance, issue of pollution where no single source causes a provable harm, but the aggregate of millions of polluters is a source of harm?

A) If a single polluter can be shown to be the cause of a provable harm to another, then this should be addressed through the courts -- i.e., the polluter can be sued for damages.

On the other hand, in the cases where an industrial society inherently generates in aggregate a level of pollution that may cause harm, but no single individual's pollution is a provable source of harm, then there is no role for government intervention. A person can't take the benefits of living in an industrial society (such as advanced medical technology that lets people to live to age 75 rather than dying at age 25), then also complain that the government should stop the Los Angeles smog that causes his eyes to water.

If you don't want to live in LA, then the proper response is to move away, not ask the government to impose environmental regulations.

[Obviously this opens up a number of interesting secondary issues, but he did not pursue this further.]

Q) Is the word "Shrugged" in "Atlas Shrugged" a verb or an adjective?

A) It's a verb. "I can't imagine a sentence in which 'shrugged' would be used an adjective."

Q) Is it legitimate for a person to make a career of theoretical science, without regard to practical application? Or must there be some attempt at application for this to be a legitimate activity?

A) As an individual scientist, this can be a totally legitimate activity. This can be part of a division of labor where someone pursues advances in theory without necessarily concerning himself with how it can be applied, whereas others use their minds to develop applications.

In a free society, someone concerned purely with theory might find it difficult to obtain funding, since most businesses would want to pay for research with some eventual practical applications. But if he had his own source of private funding or if that was how the division of labor was made, then this is fine.

From the perspective of man as such, it is not a legitimate endeavour to pursue pure theory without regard for any practical application that would benefit man's life in some way. But from the perspective of the individual scientist, a division of labor into theoreticians vs. applied scientists can be entirely legitimate.

Q) What is your favorite episode of The Twilight Zone?

A) The episode "A Nice Place to Visit", because of the deep philosophical content presented in an engaging way accessible to all viewers. He also likes the Twilight Zone series as a whole due to the good dialogue and characterizations, as well as brilliant plot twists.

[Larry Salzman notes that the full 30-minute episode can be found here on the CBS website. Thanks, Larry!]

Q) Do you have any advice on how to achieve cultural change for the better?

A) Nothing more than Ayn Rand has already said in her essay, "What Can One Do?". Namely, to write, speak out and advocate good ideas in the appropriate contexts.

Labels: , ,

Share |
   E-mail Paul Hsieh     PermaLink ()    Comments (New Page)

  Subscribe to NoodleFood Blog Posts via Feed Reader   via E-mail
Subscribe to NoodleCast Podcasts M4A via iTunes (MP3)   via Feed Reader   via E-mail

ARC Website

By Paul Hsieh @ 12:05 PM

At the "State of ARI," Yaron Brook announced that the East Coast office of ARI will be opening in September 2008, known as the Ayn Rand Center For Individual Rights.

Besides having its own website with lots of excellent content (including OpEds, videos, listings of events), they have also received permission to post two of her classic essays on individual rights and government. This is a tremendous resource for those of us who wish to point interested people towards the Objectivist position on the proper role and scope of government.

The two essays are:

Labels: ,

Share |
   E-mail Paul Hsieh     PermaLink ()    Comments (New Page)

  Subscribe to NoodleFood Blog Posts via Feed Reader   via E-mail
Subscribe to NoodleCast Podcasts M4A via iTunes (MP3)   via Feed Reader   via E-mail

 Wednesday, July 02, 2008

Highlights from OCON: Day 4

By Diana Hsieh @ 11:59 PM

Here are highlights from the Ayn Rand Institute's summer conference (a.k.a. OCON), Day Four:

Lin Zinser on "Health-Care Activism: Saving the Life Savers," Class 3 of 3:
  • Lin discussed three broad topics today: coalitions, tactics, and politics and intellectual activism.

  • Many self-described advocates of free markets, politicians and advocates, are not genuine defenders of free markets at all. They are in favor of all kinds of regulations and entitlements. At best, they wish to reduce some regulations and limit some entitlements. By clearly advocating for fully free markets, FIRM has made clear what a free market in medicine really means.

  • Lin offered six points for effective intellectual activism at the end of the lecture:

    1. Do what you are comfortable with.
    2. Have clearly stated goals with measurable deadlines.
    3. Use moral arguments and communicate at the appropriate level.
    4. Get on a mailing list -- create your own or join OActivists -- for editing, moral support, and alerts.
    5. Develop credibility and expertise by studying the issues and stating your views in a well-reasoned manner.
    6. If you have a desire to change a group's fundamental mission or platform, investigate the group and attend meetings. There may be a group where you could use moral philosophical arguments to formulate or change the policy for the entire group
Tara Smith on "The Menace of Pragmatism"
  • Tara Smith delivered yet another fantastic lecture, particularly noteworthy for her passion on the subject.

  • Smith began with as clear a description of pragmatism as possible: the concept rather fuzzy by its very nature, by the design of its advocates. She identified four features of pragmatism as a common method of thought (as opposed to a system of philosophy):

    1. Range-of-the-moment thinking
    2. Refusal or inability to think in principle
    3. Resistance to identifying things by their fundamental nature
    4. All options are kept open in decision-making

  • Smith then sketched the pervasive influence of pragmatism in the culture. (That was compelling but depressing.)

  • Next, Smith discussed the appeal and error of pragmatism. Pragmatism is particularly dangerous, Smith argued, because it sells itself as reasonable, rational, and practical. Yet in fact, pragmatism rejects reality, it rejects rationality, and it rejects practicality. It does so by rejecting long-range, conceptual, principled thought, i.e. the basic means of human survival.

  • Finally, Smith offered some suggestions for combating pragmatism in others and in oneself. Here are her suggestions, in brief:
    1. Identity it. Call it when you see it, not just to yourself and others. Show that it's not practical.
    2. Police the meaning of words. Don't let yourself be spun by the labels of others that reinforce pragmatism. Don't allow them to claim the mantle of being rational or practical. Don't allow the term "reasonable" to be a fuzzy sort-of kind of non-rationality.
    3. Defend rational idealism. Stock up instances of idealism to show that they are practical. Also, don't allow false idealism to go unchallenged.
    4. Don't give up. Remind yourself of what's at stake: to surrender to pragmatism is to surrender to the rule of irrationality.

  • To combat pragmatism in ourselves:
    1. Beware the pull of the present. The present can seem like the most important consideration. It takes deliberate effort to think long-range.
    2. Beware of the pull of the seemingly practical. Understand the practical necessity of rational principles. Adherence to principles is always the most practical, even if not always easy or convenient.
    3. Distinguish legitimate from illegitimate compromise. Be honest in your decision-making. Probe your own doubts. Listen for potential rationalization. Persevere in sorting through difficult cases. Go back to fundamentals, remind yourself of basic principles.
    4. Know thyself, and know thyself better. Identify your own vulnerabilities and blind-spots. Know what helps keep you on principle.
    5. Read and re-read Ayn Rand's works.

  • My notes posted here only scratch the surface of this excellent lecture. I highly recommend buying it whenever it becomes available from the Ayn Rand Bookstore.
Pat Corvini: "Two, Three, Four, and All That: The Sequel," Class 3 of 3:
  • Unfortunately, Pat Corvini was a bit rushed in her last lecture. So I'm clear on her view of generation of the irrational numbers, but I'm still a bit murky on the problems with the postulational method. (I can see the big picture, but not enough of the details. However, from what I do understand, the problems with attempting to generate irrational numbers via the postulational method seem hugely insurmountable.) I hope to review my notes with Paul sometime tomorrow.
Debi Ghate and Tom Bowden: "How to Be an Agent of Cultural Change"
  • A nice presentation of some of the basic steps a person can take to contribute to positive cultural change. Most of it was familiar ground to me, but I did take good notes. I'll be posting those to OActivists tomorrow.
Leonard Peikoff: "Q&A":
  • I didn't take many notes on this Q&A, so I don't have much of substance to say about it. However, Dr. Peikoff was in fine form. He was as intellectually sharp as ever, plus in a delightfully friendly and benevolent mood. He was particularly generous in answering my question about privacy lies -- or rather in explaining why he couldn't answer my question because he really couldn't say under what conditions lies to protect privacy might be legitimate because it depends too much on the particulars of the situation at hand.

  • Also, he reported that his book is going very well, that he's written a full draft o the whole text, and that he expects to be finished by the end of 2010 at the very latest.
OBloggers:
  • The informal get-together for Objectivist bloggers (a.k.a. OBloggers) was all kinds of fun. I'll have to arrange a similar event in advance next year rather than at the last minute.
Now it's finally time for bed! I'm beat!

Labels: ,

Share |
   E-mail Diana Hsieh     PermaLink ()    Comments (New Page)

  Subscribe to NoodleFood Blog Posts via Feed Reader   via E-mail
Subscribe to NoodleCast Podcasts M4A via iTunes (MP3)   via Feed Reader   via E-mail

Highlights from OCON: Day 3

By Diana Hsieh @ 12:16 AM

I don't have much to report from the third day of the Ayn Rand Institute's summer conference (a.k.a. OCON). The morning was free, so Paul and I only had two lectures to attend:

Pat Corvini: "Two, Three, Four, and All That: The Sequel," Class 2 of 3:
  • I struggled a bit with the material today, particularly the postulational method of defining various kinds of numbers, but after some discussion with Paul, that's all reasonably clear to me. However, I haven't the foggiest idea how Pat's objective approach to number will shed light on Cantor -- although I'm sure that she has something very good up her sleeve.
Dina Schein Federman's lecture "Ayn Rand as Intellectual Activist":
  • This lecture was good -- and even relevant to questions about activism today. But it wasn't eye-popping like her 2006 lecture on Ayn Rand's Home Atmosphere. In that lecture, the content was wholly new, based on Ayn Rand's family's letters to her, none of which were even translated until Dina began her work on them. That lecture was interesting in its own right, but I also enjoyed it as a total refutation Barbara Branden's very negative portrayal of Ayn Rand's relationship with her family.
Tomorrow is the final day of the first half of the conference. It's going to be busy. We'll start with the final lecture of Lin Zinser's course, then Tara Smith's lecture on pragmatism, then the final lecture of Pat Corvini's course, then the ARI Open House including the Workshop on Cultural Change, then the Q&A with Leonard Peikoff, and finally an informal meeting of Objectivist Bloggers.

I'm tired just thinking about it!

Labels: ,

Share |
   E-mail Diana Hsieh     PermaLink ()    Comments (New Page)

  Subscribe to NoodleFood Blog Posts via Feed Reader   via E-mail
Subscribe to NoodleCast Podcasts M4A via iTunes (MP3)   via Feed Reader   via E-mail

 Monday, June 30, 2008

The Next 3 OCONs

By Paul Hsieh @ 11:34 PM

Yaron Brook announced the dates and locations for the next three OCON conferences:
2009: July 3-11, Boston, MA, Seaport Hotel
2010: July 2-10, Las Vegas, NV, Red Rock Resort
2011: July 1-9, Ft. Lauderdale, FL, Marriott Harbor Beach Resort

Labels: ,

Share |
   E-mail Paul Hsieh     PermaLink ()    Comments (New Page)

  Subscribe to NoodleFood Blog Posts via Feed Reader   via E-mail
Subscribe to NoodleCast Podcasts M4A via iTunes (MP3)   via Feed Reader   via E-mail

Highlights from OCON: Day 2

By Diana Hsieh @ 4:23 PM

Here are some more highlights from the second day of the Ayn Rand Institute's summer conference (a.k.a. OCON).

Lin Zinser on "Health-Care Activism: Saving the Life Savers," Class 2 of 3:
Today, Lin discussed some strategies for successful activism, connecting those lessons to her own experience with FIRM. (Some of her stories would be very surprising to most people -- in a good way.)
Robert Mayhew on "Thales and the Birth of Philosophy in Ancient Greece":
This lecture was a fascinating discussion of the birth of philosophy, particularly the radical departure from primitive supernaturalism that began with Thales in ancient Greece. Thales inaugurated the study of philosophy as an explicit discipline on the basis of observation and rational argument -- as opposed to relying on traditional myths to explain natural phenomena. Mayhew clearly showed the radical differences between the methods of Thales and those of thinkers in other cultures at the time. Mayhew also traced the unique factors in ancient Greek culture that made possible (but not necessary) the development of explicit philosophy.

I particularly enjoyed the lessons for the prospects for Objectivism at the end of the lecture.

(The lecture was related to Dr. Mayhew's essay criticizing Robert Tracinski's analysis of the role of philosophy in history, posted to NoodleFood in January 2007.)
Pat Corvini: "Two, Three, Four, and All That: The Sequel," Class 1 of 3:
This course examines three modern ideas in mathematics: (1) equivalent sets, (2) the postulational method, and (3) the continuum and actual infinities. Today, Pat explained the basics of Cantor's arguments about comparisons of sets, with a few hints of the criticisms to come. (I remembered that somewhat fuzzily from my undergraduate course in philosophy of mathematics.) Tomorrow and the next day, she'll lay out the standard the postulational method, and then discuss the Objectivist approach to these topics. (Very cool!)

This course is a sequel to her excellent course of last year: Two, Three, Four, and All That.
That's all for today!

Labels: ,

Share |
   E-mail Diana Hsieh     PermaLink ()    Comments (New Page)

  Subscribe to NoodleFood Blog Posts via Feed Reader   via E-mail
Subscribe to NoodleCast Podcasts M4A via iTunes (MP3)   via Feed Reader   via E-mail

Highlights from OCON: Day 1 Addendum

By Diana Hsieh @ 8:12 AM

In my first report on OCON yesterday, I forgot to mention that OCON is huge again: over 400 people are attending. The sheer number of people I don't know is rather overwhelming.

By way of context, last year, over 500 people attended for the 50th anniversary of celebration of Atlas Shrugged in Telluride. Before than, around 300 was average. So it seems that the conference has experienced more than just a transient increase in size over the past two years.

Labels: ,

Share |
   E-mail Diana Hsieh     PermaLink ()    Comments (New Page)

  Subscribe to NoodleFood Blog Posts via Feed Reader   via E-mail
Subscribe to NoodleCast Podcasts M4A via iTunes (MP3)   via Feed Reader   via E-mail

 Sunday, June 29, 2008

Highlights from OCON: Day 1

By Diana Hsieh @ 11:50 PM

I'm attending the Ayn Rand Institute's summer conference (a.k.a. OCON this week. So in lieu of regular blogging, I thought I'd try to post a few brief highlights each day.

Lin Zinser on "Health-Care Activism: Saving the Life Savers," Class 1 of 3:
  • An excellent first class. Inspiring review of the accomplishments of Freedom and Individual Rights in Medicine (FIRM). Fascinating discussion of the rise, fall, and rise of state laws licensing doctors to practice medicine.

  • Kind of Activism: Intellectual activism means changing the ideas of honest, intellectually active people. Political activism means directing your legislators on how to vote. Political activism is not primary: the real change must be in the culture.
Yaron Brook on "Cultural Movements: Creating Change," Lecture 1 of 3:
  • A fascinating overview of the successes and failures of the economic defense of free markets from the 1960s to the 1990s and the environmental movement from the 1970s to today. (I'm eager to hear the rest of these lectures! They'll definitely be worth buying.)
... drumroll please ...

Yaron Brook on "State of ARI":

These are just a few highlights:
  • ARI has shipped 1.1 million books as part of the "Free Books for Teachers" program. So if the books have a lifespan of four to five years, then four to five million students are reading Ayn Rand's novels in their English classes. By the end of the decade, over seven million kids will have read Ayn Rand.

  • BB&T has funded 38 programs in the southeast US for the study of capitalism and philosophy.

  • DC Office will be opened with four staff members just five blocks from the White House in August.

  • Yowza! An anonymous donor donated one million and one dollars just this afternoon. That's ARI's largest single donation ever -- by a dollar. So ARI's projected revenues for 2008 will be nine million dollars.
That's all for now!

Further Reports on OCON:

Labels: ,

Share |
   E-mail Diana Hsieh     PermaLink ()    Comments (New Page)

  Subscribe to NoodleFood Blog Posts via Feed Reader   via E-mail
Subscribe to NoodleCast Podcasts M4A via iTunes (MP3)   via Feed Reader   via E-mail

  

NoodleFoodlers


Diana Hsieh, Ph.D
diana@dianahsieh.com
@DianaHsieh


Paul Hsieh, MD
paul@paulhsieh.com
@PaulHsieh


Greg Perkins
greg@eCosmos.com
@gregperk

About the NoodleFoodlers
E-mail the NoodleFoodlers

DH's Projects

My blog NoodleFood covers anything and everything, including my whole collection of NoodleCast podcasts.

Rationally Selfish offers principled and practical advice for living well.

My other online projects include Explore Atlas Shrugged, PhiloFiles, and OList Mailing Lists.

NoodleFood

All Recent Comments

Posts by RSS Feed
Posts via E-mail
Follow on Facebook

Monthly Archives
NoodleCaboodle
Diana's Blogroll

Blogger Trackbacks
Technorati Trackbacks
Reader Map

NoodleCast

Posts by RSS Feed
Posts via E-mail

M4A Podcasts in iTunes
MP3 Podcasts in iTunes

Follow NF on Facebook

Objectivism

Ayn Rand Lexicon
The Objective Standard
Ayn Rand Institute
Ayn Rand Center
OCON Conferences
Anthem Foundation
Ayn Rand Society
ARC TV

Community Groups
Front Range Objectivism
DC Objectivist Salon
Golden Gate Objectivists
Chicago Objectivist Society
Great Lakes Objectivists
Minnesota Objectivist Assn
Kansas City Objectivists
Ohio Objectivist Society
Houston Objectivism Society
Northwest Objectivists

Objectivist Club Network
The Undercurrent
Campus Clubs

Explore Atlas Shrugged

OList E-mail Lists
OActivists
OBloggers
OAcademics
OGrownups
OEvolve

False Objectivism

Activism

Clemson Institute
FIRM
AFCM
Secular Gov't
FA/RM

Objectivists

Leonard Peikoff
John David Lewis
Yaron Brook
Andrew Bernstein
Ellen Kenner
Paul Hsieh
Diana Hsieh

Personal

Meredith Brickell Ceramics
NetFlix Friends

Blogroll

Funny

Go Fug Yourself
Cake Wrecks
FAIL Blog
Photobomb
People of Walmart
Emails From Crazy People
Passive-Aggressive Notes
Awkward Family Photos
There, I Fixed It
Probably Bad News
Angry People
Wedinator
Oddly Specific
Epic Win
Autocomplete Me
GraphJam
Regretsy
Poorly Dressed
"Unnecessary" Quotes
Broken Picture Telephone
Twaxed.com
Overheard in New York
My Life Is Average
Today's Big Thing

Objectivists

Rational Jenn
The Little Things
Trey Givens
GeekPress
Ari Armstrong
Free Colorado
Daily Improvisation
Gus Van Horn
Titanic Deck Chairs
Thrutch
The Crucible
Ramen & Rand
The Morality War
OActivity
Objectivism for Living
CareerMama
John and Ansley
Sacred Ego
The Hoondat Report
Myrhaf
Kindredist
Try Reason!
Mike's Eyes
Software Nerd
One Reality
3 Ring Binder
Valzhalla
Robbservations
Logical Disconnect
Applying Philosophy
History At Our House
Non-Trivial Pursuit
TalkObjectivism
Shaving Leviathan
Rant from the Rock
Classical Values
Principled Parent
New Clarion
Rational Passion
Objectivism Korea
Prometheus
Ping-Ponging...
Hand Waving...
Philosophical Mortician
Canadian Republic
Daily Layman
Dirty Kuffar
Reddie Reasons
Witch Doctor Repellent
Benevolent Misanthropy
Truth, Justice...
Making Progress
Edge of Reason
Fun With Gravity
Art, Love, & Philosophy
Galileo Blogs
Aesthetic Capitalist
Optional Values
Individualist Outlook
Born to Identify
Erosophia
Haight Speech
Pedagogically Correct
Leitmotif
Personal Development
Ad Hoc
Alexander Marriott
American Individualist
Armchair Intellectual
Secular Foxhole
Capitalist Lion
Literatrix
John McVey
Wayne's Dirty Lab
Lyle's Blog
Eleutherian Laureate
Pomponazzi Ponders
One Minute Case
Philosophical Detective
A Damascus Sword
Heroes of Capitalism
Superhero Babylon
Just Add Rationality
Tito's Blog
Orpheus Remembered
Dad Rewrite
Libertas Immortalis
Theory to Practice
Benpercent
Simply Capitalism
Heroes of Capitalism
Flibbertigibbet
Rule of Reason
Ms. Think
Spark A Synapse
Miranda Barzey
Money Speech
Save the Humans
PhilosopherEagle
Talking To Myself
Cox & Forkum
noumenalself

Food/Health

Dr. Michael Eades
Free the Animal
Whole Health Source
Heart Scan
Mark's Daily Apple
Sous Vide Supreme
Sous Vide Cooking
My Paleo Kitchen
Fitness Spotlight
Go Frolic
Brad Pilon
IF Life
Fitness Fixation
Fitness Spotlight
CrossFit
Healthy Cooking Coach
PaNu
Livin' La Vida Low Carb
Primal Wisdom
Tom Naughton
Grain-Free Foodies
Caveman Food
Cheeseslave
Cook Like Your Grandmother
Nourished Kitchen
Local Nourishment
Whole Story
Nourishing Gourmet
Kitchen Garden Network
Cake and Commerce
Food Renegade
Experience Life
Barefoot Ted's Adventures
Mother Earth News
Fat Head
Hyperlipid
Low Carb Age
Natural Bias
Nutrition and Physical Regeneration
Prometheus Unleashed
Slow Burn
Praying to Darwin
Hunter Angler Gardener Cook
Homegrown Evolution
Action Healthy Life
Unleashed
Dr. Jonny Bowden
Liberating Education
Cooking in our Cave
At Darwin's Table
Son of Grok
Lorette C. Luzajic
Lovin' It Low Carb
Mary Dan Eades
Great Health From Real Food
Blood Sugar 101
Conditioning Research
Local Forage
Barbarian Blog
Honest Meat
The Bovine
Kimberly Hartke
Raisin Hell
Matters To Me
Living Paleo
Rambling Outside the Box
Complete Patient
Christopher Kimball
Cooking Issues

Advice

Miss Manners
Carolyn Hax

Sources

Urlesque
Mashable
Boing Boing
Cynical-C
Neuroworld
Mental Floss

Computing

TUAW
Mac Gems
Mac OS X Tips
O'Reilly Mac Blog
TwiTip
Jesse Newhart

Advocates

We Stand FIRM
Politics without God
Principles in Practice
The Undercurrent
Randex
Capitalism Magazine
Voices for Reason
ARC-TV
The Torch

Politics

TheAgitator.com
Volokh Conspiracy
Dynamist Blog
Marginal Revolution
Patient Power
Instapundit.com
Little Green Footballs
Fly Bottle
Tim Sandefur
Miscellaneous Objections
The Cauldron
Overlawyered
Secular Right
Tom G Palmer
Liberty and Power
Positive Liberty
Daily Dish
EconLog
Discriminations

Family

Travels with Daisy
Jamie's Travel Log

Children

Katie Allison Granju
FreeRangeKids
Dooce
Joanne Jacobs

Productivity

Lifehacker
43 Folders
Daytipper
3 Things Today
LifeHack
DIY Life
Steve Pavlina
Daily Writing Tips
Manager Tools Blog
GTDtimes
Unclutterer
Productivity501
Gina Trapani
Four Hour Work Week
Joel on Software
Jason Crawford
Organizing Professionals
Evernote Blogcast

Miscellany

Pharyngula
Whedonesque
Deep Glamour
Leiter Reports
Cranky Professor
Philosopher Stone
Rhyme of the Day
Shawn Klein
Mudita Journal
Bioblog by Biotunes
Tightly Wound
WaiterRant

Archives

March 2002
April 2002
May 2002
June 2002
July 2002
August 2002
September 2002
October 2002
November 2002
December 2002
January 2003
February 2003
March 2003
April 2003
May 2003
June 2003
July 2003
August 2003
October 2003
November 2003
December 2003
January 2004
February 2004
March 2004
April 2004
May 2004
June 2004
July 2004
August 2004
September 2004
October 2004
November 2004
December 2004
January 2005
February 2005
March 2005
April 2005
May 2005
June 2005
July 2005
August 2005
September 2005
October 2005
November 2005
December 2005
January 2006
February 2006
March 2006
April 2006
May 2006
June 2006
July 2006
August 2006
September 2006
October 2006
November 2006
December 2006
January 2007
February 2007
March 2007
April 2007
May 2007
June 2007
July 2007
August 2007
September 2007
October 2007
November 2007
December 2007
January 2008
February 2008
March 2008
April 2008
May 2008
June 2008
July 2008
August 2008
September 2008
October 2008
November 2008
December 2008
January 2009
February 2009
March 2009
April 2009
May 2009
June 2009
July 2009
August 2009
September 2009
October 2009
November 2009
December 2009
January 2010
February 2010
March 2010

NoodleFood at Blogged